Teamwork and Quick Thinking on Display at 23rd Annual Mock Trial
The 2026 Justice J.B. Shaughnessy Mock Trial at St. Michael’s College School (SMCS) gave Grade 12 law students the opportunity to step into a courtroom setting and get a first-hand look into the legal system.
Designed as a simulated court proceeding, the event allowed students to assume the roles of lawyers and witnesses and present legal arguments before a panel of judges. With eight judges presiding over the proceedings, the atmosphere closely mirrored a real courtroom, adding both intensity and authenticity to the experience.
Students worked in teams preparing their cases, focusing on legal research, argument development, and oral presentation skills. Each side was responsible for presenting a clear, persuasive argument, responding to the judges’ questions, and defending their position with evidence and reasoning. The judges’ questioning challenged students to think on their feet, demonstrating not only their knowledge of the case but also their ability to communicate effectively under pressure.
Throughout the day, students showcased impressive levels of preparation, and professionalism. The mock trial emphasized key skills such as critical thinking, collaboration, and public speaking. It also highlighted the importance of organization and attention to detail, as students needed to construct logical arguments and anticipate counterarguments from the opposing side.
“What stood out was how prepared and focused the students were,” says Dr. Daniel Lumsden ’96, community engagement and learning lead. “They worked through complex arguments, challenged each other’s positions, and handled the back-and-forth with confidence. Along the way, they built skills that don’t just apply to law—things like clear communication, teamwork, and quick thinking.”
The presence of eight judges added increased credibility and provided students with diverse perspectives and feedback. Their questions and evaluations pushed participants to refine their thinking and elevate their performance throughout the day.
Congratulations to Georgios Koutoumanos on being named top oralist and winner of the St. Thomas More Legal Advocacy & Shaughnessy Family Award. His success reflected not only strong legal reasoning and preparation, but also exceptional communication and teamwork.
“The mock trial was an incredibly rewarding experience. It taught me to stay calm under pressure, think on the spot, and speak with confidence,” says Koutoumanos. “I am proud of what I accomplished, thankful for my teammates, and grateful to Mr. Tropea for the guidance he has given us.”
Beyond the competition itself, the event served as another important experiential learning opportunity for students.
“Students gained a deeper understanding of how the legal system operates and how arguments are structured and evaluated in a courtroom setting,” adds Lumsden. “They were also provided with valuable insight into potential future pathways in law, politics, and public service, while helping students build confidence in their abilities.”
Related links: